Factory Automation

Insights

Insights. SV-P Series Die-Sinking EDM Machine: Semiconductor Package Option. The challenges faced when Mitsubishi Electric EDMs entered the semiconductor industry. Part 2. A ray of hope emerges

Not a moment to lose

Semiconductors are the foundation of modern industry; a crucial component that underpins the whole manufacturing sector. They are used in everything from smartphones and laptops to internet-enabled home appliances and electric vehicles, so the market for them is booming. The current surge in generative AI driven solutions means there will be even greater demand, in the years to come, for semiconductors, which are vital for high-speed processing of large volumes of data.

However, while a considerable number of Mitsubishi Electric’s Factory Automation (FA) products and solutions have been adopted by the semiconductor manufacturing sector, there were much lower sales rates for EDM machines. That’s what made the Mitsubishi Electric team so keen to succeed with the semiconductor encapsulation mold project, as it would allow it to get a stronger foothold in this industry.

Standing in front of the EDM machine that had been returned to the Nagoya Works, Sasaki, Hikosaka and Nakagawa vowed not to give up. They decided to continue the development project, believing that if they carried on making improvements, this would surely help create commercial opportunities in the semiconductor industry.

Turned away at the door

An opportunity came sooner than expected. In July 2021, Mitsubishi Electric had a technical roundtable meeting with CAPABLE Corporation, a fabless manufacturer of semiconductor encapsulation molds. These “Technology Roundtables” are considered forums for collaboration, where Mitsubishi Electric and customers bring together cutting-edge technologies to explore new possibilities for collaboration.

Established in 2012 as a spin-out of executives and engineers from a major semiconductor equipment manufacturer, CAPABLE designs encapsulation molds used in semiconductor production. A key feature is that as a fabless manufacturer, CAPABLE does not have its own manufacturing facilities but instead outsources the manufacture of the molds it designs. With several Japanese manufacturers as partners, the company’s business model is to design molds to be produced by partners and supplied to semiconductor production companies.

image:CAPABLE LOGO

CAPABLE is a fabless manufacturer, established with the aim of revitalizing Japan’s mold industry. Mold production is outsourced to Japanese mold makers, and products are supplied to major international manufacturers of semiconductors, LEDs, and electronics under the CAPABLE brand. CAPABLE is the first company in Japan to use this business model.

  • CAPABLE Corporation : http://capableeng.com/en/index.html
  • The company, which outsources mold fabrication to multiple manufacturers, has a strong influence over the selection of processing machines used by its subcontractors, which made any roundtable technical discussion with CAPABLE, a great opportunity. Hikosaka explained that he was developing a die-sinking EDM machine to produce semiconductor molds, however, the CAPABLE representatives shared their opinion that:

    “In the field of semiconductor encapsulation mold manufacturing, Mitsubishi Electric’s EDM machines are at the lowest end of the scale.”

    Hikosaka was speechless. He knew the sales results were very low, but was their reputation really that bad? A few days later, he visited CAPABLE with an encapsulation mold processed using the EDM machine from the earlier trial. He thought it was reasonably well made, but it was rejected immediately by the CAPABLE team. They identified that there were visible inconsistencies in the roughness, so there was no point in even measuring it.

    Hikosaka was disappointed by this evaluation, but he knew that if they gave up now all their work would have been for nothing. Mitsubishi Electric’s EDM machines might never have another chance to get into the ever-expanding semiconductor market.

    “You don’t know how much you can do until you try.
    Let’s give it our best shot.”

    Hikosaka went to Mitsubishi Electric’s policy meeting, where development decisions are made, and proposed creating a die-sinking EDM for the semiconductor market. The proposal was approved by the company executives. At the same time, Sasaki began working on the conditions for a new sample to re-propose to CAPABLE at the next opportunity.

    “Mission to cut the processing time in half”

    In January 2022, six months after Hikosaka had been turned away, a new sample was ready. This time, they had achieved the required surface quality. After looking at the new sample, the CAPABLE engineers commented favorably on the surface quality, but pointed out a productivity concern: the processing time was too long.

    “Our partners won’t invest in a machine with such a long processing time. Can you cut it in half?

    There was a reason behind CAPABLE’s insistence on short processing times. Yoichi Kawahara, the founder and president of CAPABLE, was previously president of a major semiconductor manufacturing equipment manufacturer. There, most of the molds they used were made in-house.

    However, the semiconductor market is prone to economic cycles with peaks and troughs in demand meaning that often in-house production cannot keep up with demand during busy periods. Ideally, those manufacturers would like to outsource mold production, but the quality cannot always be guaranteed.

    Yoichi Kawahara saw first-hand how this weakened the molding industry in Japan. With this in mind he founded CAPABLE as a fabless encapsulation mold manufacturer to provide a service that could guarantee the quality of molds made by subcontractors, with the aim of revitalizing Japan’s molding industry as well as increasing quality for semiconductor manufacturers.

    For CAPABLE to guarantee the quality of molds, they wanted to avoid relying on the technical capabilities of individual partners. In other words, rather than a manufacturing process based on on-site improvements, the processing machine itself needed to be a complete turnkey solution with high levels of quality and productivity. This is why CAPABLE demanded such high standards for both surface quality and processing time from the very start.

    Mitsubishi Electric had heard about the ideas of Yoichi Kawahara and the other founding members of CAPABLE. To meet those expectations, Mitsubishi Electric would need to cut the machine processing time in half. Now that the surface quality requirements had been met, Hikosaka and his team promised to improve the processing time.

    image:processing time

    The team had just five months to work out how to halve the processing time

    Existing customers start to look for alternative solutions

    The engineers were starting to see positive results in the development of the die-sinking EDM machine for semiconductor encapsulation molds. But just as the mood in the development team, which had been low since the rejection of the trial machine, was finally brightening, they received some devastating news. A long-term user of Mitsubishi Electric’s EDMs had decided to switch to a competitor’s die-sinking EDM.

    This customer had continuously used Mitsubishi Electric’s wire-cut and die-sinking EDMs, and a good relationship had been built up over time, so the sudden replacement decision was a shock for the Mitsubishi Electric team, especially as the reason given was “the need to produce semiconductor encapsulation molds.” The lack of an EDM machine with this capability was now not only affecting new customers but also existing customers.

    This put even more pressure on Hikosaka and the rest of the development team. Hikosaka spoke to the customer about what led to the replacement decision and how they intend to use the new machines. Thanks to the good relationship with the customer, he learned much which reinforced his belief that the key to development lay in improving the power supply.

    CAPABLE was also pressing for another delivery sample, so without a moment to lose, Hikosaka returned to the Nagoya Works and attempted to speed up development.

    SV-P Series Die-Sinking EDM Machine Semiconductor Package

    With the growing spread of 5G technology and battery electric vehicles, there is increasing demand for semiconductors.
    To address this need, Mitsubishi Electric has developed its semiconductor package option, which supports the production of semiconductor encapsulation molds, a vital part of the semiconductor manufacturing process.

    Prev

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3
    4. 4

    Next

    Back to list